We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies.More info
Josh Dawson Real EstateJosh Dawson Real Estate
Call Us:

614.706.6288

Message Us:

[email protected]

    • Meet Josh
    • Success Stories
    • Our Blog
    • Get In Touch
    • Seller Services
    • Get Your Home's Value
    • Marketing Strategy
    • Buyer Services
    • Search for Homes
    • Call Us:

      614.706.6288

    • Message Us:

      [email protected]

    Featured Image

    Your Listing Expired - Now What?

    Understanding Your Expired Listing: A New Opportunity Awaits As a homeowner, experiencing an expired listing can be discouraging,...

    • Josh Dawson
    • December 28th, 2023
    • 8 min read

    Understanding Your Expired Listing: A New Opportunity Awaits

    As a homeowner, experiencing an expired listing can be discouraging, but it also opens the door to new possibilities. This is a moment to reassess and pivot strategies for a more successful outcome. By understanding the reasons behind the expiration, whether it's market dynamics, pricing strategy, or presentation, you can tailor a more effective approach. Let's explore how, with the right insight and expertise, you can transform this setback into an opportunity for a successful sale. Here are some actionable tips and guidance to reignite interest in your property.

    Understanding Why Your Home Didn't Sell

    It's important to recognize that several factors could have influenced why your home didn't sell during its initial listing. Market conditions, such as shifts in buyer demand or changes in the local real estate landscape, can play a significant role. Additionally, the pricing strategy for your home is crucial; an overpriced property often deters potential buyers. Presentation is another key aspect - the way your home is staged and marketed can greatly impact buyer interest. Let's dive into each of these elements to understand better how they might have affected your home's sale prospects.

    Having Proper Access

    Limiting viewing times, such as only on certain days or avoiding weekends, can hinder the selling process. Broad accessibility is key in any market to attract more buyers, which can positively impact both the selling price and time on the market. Consider making your home available for showings at more flexible times to enhance its marketability and appeal to a wider range of potential buyers.

    Making It Look Good

    To enhance the appeal of your home and increase its chances of selling, it's important to make it look inviting. While hiring a professional stager is ideal, it may not always be feasible due to budget constraints. However, there are still effective ways to improve your home's appearance. Consider investing in a can of paint to refresh a room that needs it. Cleaning the carpets, perhaps even doing it yourself with a rented steam cleaner, can also make a significant difference. Additionally, organizing a garage sale to declutter spaces like the garage can greatly enhance the overall appeal of your home to potential buyers.

    Pricing It Compellingly

    In the real estate market, the price of your home is often the most critical factor influencing its sale. It's so influential that it can offset other aspects like accessibility or condition. A well-priced home is likely to sell, regardless of other factors.

    As your listing has recently expired, it's essential to re-evaluate your initial asking price. Consider how it may have hindered the sale. This process involves more than just a basic Current Market Analysis (CMA). It requires a deep understanding of the current real estate market trends and factors impacting prices in your area.

    Take the time to review detailed market data, including graphs and charts, to fully grasp the market's demands. This information is crucial in setting the right price for your home, ensuring it aligns with market expectations and enhances its appeal to potential buyers.

    Understanding Your Next Steps

    It's important to recognize that several factors could have influenced why your home didn't sell during its initial listing. Market conditions, such as shifts in buyer demand or changes in the local real estate landscape, can play a significant role. Additionally, the pricing strategy for your home is crucial; an overpriced property often deters potential buyers. Presentation is another key aspect - the way your home is staged and marketed can greatly impact buyer interest. Let's dive into each of these elements to understand better how they might have affected your home's sale prospects.

    Re-List with Your Current Agent

    If your home didn't sell by the time your listing expired, you might be reflecting on various factors such as the challenging nature of the housing market, an overly ambitious listing price, or not fully considering advice given to you. In light of this, you may be considering giving your real estate agent another chance. This is a perfectly valid decision.

    Should you choose to relist with the same agent, it's important to clearly understand the terms of your new agreement. Particularly, be aware of how long you are extending your contract for. Sometimes, agents request an additional week or so to follow up with a potential buyer who has shown interest. This extended listing might not always be immediately visible in the MLS (Multiple Listing Service), so you may not be immediately aware of the new contract termination date.

    If you're extending the contract for more than a few days, it will likely be listed in the MLS, and you can check there for the updated expiration date. Remember, this decision is about what's best for you and your property, so weigh your options carefully and proceed in a way that aligns with your goals.

    Take Your House off the Market

    When you find yourself thinking about taking your home off the market because it didn’t sell, it's natural to feel a sense of disappointment. It’s common to start rationalizing the situation by thinking that maybe you didn't really want to sell the house, or that making a move right now doesn’t make sense. This is a normal human response to avoid feeling let down.

    However, it's important to revisit the reasons that led you to put your home on the market in the first place. What were your original goals and aspirations? If these reasons were valid a few months ago, they are likely still relevant now.

    Don't let this setback diminish your dreams and goals. The fact that your house didn’t sell during the last listing period doesn't mean it will never sell or that it shouldn't be sold. Reflect on your original objectives and reignite that ambition. You deserve to achieve your goals, and sometimes that means persevering through challenges and not giving up on your dreams.

    List the House For-Sale-By-Owner (FSBO)

    If your home didn't sell and you're considering the For Sale By Owner (FSBO) route, it's important to acknowledge your feelings towards the process. You might feel frustrated with your previous agent, thinking about what they could have done differently or what they did that was aggravating. It's perfectly okay to feel this way and to reflect on these experiences. They can help you understand what you expect and value in a real estate professional.

    However, it's crucial not to generalize your experience with one agent to all real estate professionals. Think of it like getting a bad haircut. You don't stop getting haircuts altogether; you simply look for a better hairstylist. Similarly, in every profession, there are both good and bad professionals. This doesn't mean you should forgo their services entirely. Instead, it means finding the right person for your needs.

    If you're dissatisfied with your previous real estate experience, don't let that stop you from seeking help again. Just like you would change financial advisors, consider working with a different real estate agent who might better align with your expectations and needs. Each agent brings a unique approach, and finding the right one could make a significant difference in successfully selling your home.

    Hiring a New Agent

     

    If your home listing expired and you're considering relisting with a different real estate agent, there are several key aspects to focus on to ensure you make the right choice.

    Remember, the aim is to find an agent who can effectively meet your needs and help you achieve your goals. Don't hesitate to switch to a new agent if they seem more aligned with your requirements and if they instill a sense of trust and confidence.

    What to Look for in an Agent

    Seeking Rapport with a New Agent: It's essential to find an agent with whom you feel comfortable and understood. Look for someone who shows genuine interest in your needs and concerns, and makes a positive first impression.

    Clarifying Your Needs 

    Clearly communicate your expectations and goals for the sale of your house. Look for an agent who is willing to listen and take notes, ensuring they understand exactly what you're looking for.

    Evaluating the Agent’s Company

    Understand the value proposition of the agent’s company. What unique benefits does it offer? Why should you choose this firm over others? Consider how the company’s strengths align with your specific selling needs.

    Understanding the Agent’s Personal Value

    Assess the individual agent’s qualifications, such as their market knowledge, designations, and any additional services they offer. You want to be sure they have the expertise and resources necessary to effectively market and sell your home.

    Building Trust

     Trust is crucial. You need an agent who exudes confidence and expertise, someone you can rely on to sell your house. Look for an agent with the heart of a teacher, not just a salesman – someone who educates and guides you through the selling process.

    WORK WITH ME

    Let Me Be Your Guide

    My goal is simple, to help you make better real estate decisions.

    Author Photo
    About the author

    Josh Dawson

    614.706.6288
    • facebook
    • X
    • instagram
    • linkedin
    • youtube
    Buying or selling real estate is more than a transaction—it’s a major life decision. You deserve a guide who brings not just experience, but clarity, strategy, and trust to the table. That’s where I come in. I was born and raised in Fostoria, Ohio—a blue-collar factory town where your word meant everything and people treated each other with respect. I come from a family of military veterans, tradesmen, and kind-hearted Midwesterners who taught me to do good, be good, and work hard. I carried those values with me to Ohio Wesleyan University, where I played football and graduated with the same commitment to perseverance and teamwork I bring to every client relationship today. My real estate career began not in Central Ohio, but as part of a Wall Street Journal Top 100 Team in Boston—one of the fastest-moving, most competitive markets in the country. Before real estate, I served in senior political roles, including State Director for the Massachusetts State Treasurer and Legislative Director in the State Senate. I even ran for State Representative and earned an endorsement from The Boston Globe—because I’ve always been driven to serve people, solve complex problems, and lead with integrity. Today, I bring those same values into my work as a real estate professional and former managing broker. I’ve led agents, negotiated complicated transactions, and taught hundreds of professionals how to master real estate contracts. I don’t just understand the fine print—I’ve taught from it. That insight often helps me make small but strategic contract adjustments that protect my clients or save them tens of thousands of dollars. I currently serve on the Columbus Realtors Broker Advisory Committee and am the Past-President of the Greater Dublin Realty Association, where I continue to advocate for professionalism, education, and client-first service across our industry. Clients know me for my steady communication and proactive approach. I hold weekly check-ins to ensure no one ever wonders, “What’s happening?” or “What’s next?” Whether I’m guiding a family through an emotional sale or helping a first-time buyer make a strong start, I act with clarity, empathy, and your long-term goals in mind. When I’m not working, you’ll often find me coaching my daughter’s softball team, spending time with my family, or fishing and boating in Port Clinton, where my parents now live. I live in Dublin with my amazing wife and our two beautiful daughters—and I consider it an honor to serve families across Central Ohio with focus, care, and professionalism. If you're ready to move forward with purpose, I’m here to help you do it wisely.

    Similar posts like this

    Featured Listings

    Your Next Chapter Starts Here: Bethel Village Condo in Top-Rated Dublin Schools

    Welcome to 2511 Gardenia Drive, a move-in ready condo nestled in the highly sought-after Bethel Village community—offeri...
    Read more

    Modern Luxury Meets Ultimate Comfort in Marysville's Adena Pointe

    Discover this stunning 2023-built Blair floorplan in Adena Pointe. With 3,000+ sq ft, a gourmet kitchen, rec room with t...
    Read more

    Location, Location, Location: How to Pick the Perfect Neighborhood

    Learn how to choose the ideal neighborhood for your lifestyle, budget, and long-term happiness with these practical tips...
    Read more
    Josh Dawson Real Estate

    Helping people make better real estate decisions.

    5404 Tara Hill Drive, Dublin, OH 43017

    5404 Tara Hill Drive, Dublin, OH 43017

    Call Us:

    614.706.6288

    Message Us:

    [email protected]

    Footer Links

    • Meet Josh
    • Client Success Stories
    • Get In Touch
    • Our Blog
    • Seller Services
    • Get Your Home's Value
    • Buyer Services
    • Search for Homes
    Privacy Policy

    © 2025

    Powered by